Along with all the other MoveOn.org members, I received your recent emails, and I have a few observations. First, Mr. Gore, I want to thank you for appealing simultaneously to our practical and our frugal sides from the very beginning, especially with your suggestion that a contribution of $25.00 will, among other things, "solve the Climate Crisis" and "regain our nation's moral authority in the world." These feats, Mr. Gore, would take a miracle, which is the only reason I can possibly imagine that in a letter to a bunch of lefties and liberals you would end with a quote from The Bible. This quote--"Where there is no vision, the people perish"--is a good one, mind you. It's well chosen and relevant. But speaking as a rhetoric specialist, I think you might have more luck with the MoveOn readership if you quoted from another, more heavily monitored and consistently reliable source--say Wikipedia.
Mr. King, I read with interest your Halloween email--the one titled "I know scary"--the one that goes on to intimate that the Bush administration is the scariest thing since that one book you wrote about the car bearing a woman's name that flashed its headlights angrily on its murderous rampages. That shit scared me sleepless, and so at base I agree with your comparison. But something else about your note bothers me more deeply, and it has to do with something like authenticity. You are a writer, Mr. King, and it's difficult for me to imagine your writing (or even approving) sentences as colloquial as this, its email format notwithstanding: "The failure in Iraq and the recent string of scandals have put a bunch of new
districts into play." And my personal favorite, "Thankfully, this national nightmare is one we can end with--literally--a wake up
call." Surely you would agree with me that the wake up call you refer to still counts as figurative usage, and that a literal wake up call would need a beige colored push button phone with a startling orange light in a grimy hotel room, the likes of which few Republican congressmen would ever be caught in, page or no. You had a great metaphor going--why muck it up with the word literally?
And to our friends at MoveOn.org: I realize that some of us may not be reading your emails that carefully, and that this is likely the reason you offered to ghostwrite for Mr. Gore and Mr. King. But you should know that Eli Pariser and Tom Matzzie enjoy their own kind of celebrity with us MoveOn-ers (especially since The New Yorker ran its sleek spread on lefty activists including Pariser), and even though I admit I haven't had the time to read each message they sent, I appreciate their directness, and their occasional cursewords, even if I sometimes wonder about their unwaveringly alarmist tones. Oh, and if you're thinking of changing media--like that time last week when one of your representatives called me at home? You might want to rethink that. Phones are old school and therefore sacred, and email is going the way of the phone. I'm sure you know better than to try mass mailing, since we are mostly dutiful recyclers. Texting and IMing might be the way to go, but I can't speak for the rest of the readership on that score. I myself haven't gotten into either of those.
Bring back Eli, please. As much as I get a kick out of receiving emails from you two, I'd hate to think that MoveOn has run its course.
Sincerely yours,
Debra Hawhee
MoveOn member at both my email addresses
Recent Comments